Researcher calls for 鈥榬igorous evaluation鈥� of justice tech in recent article discussed on Talk Justice podcast
颁辞苍迟补肠迟鈥赌赌�鈥赌赌赌赌赌赌�
Kathryn Fanlund
Communications and Social Media Manager听
(202) 295-1520听听听听听听听听听听听
Contact Us鈥�����赌赌赌赌赌赌�
奥础厂贬滨狈骋罢翱狈听鈥� Significant gaps remain in research on justice technology, according to a recent article published by the American Bar Foundation. Author Jason Tashea joined host Cat Moon for a of the Talk Justice podcast, where they discussed these gaps, as well as other critical areas for expanding research into technology initiatives of the justice system, courts and legal aid organizations.听
Tashea is director of technology, data and knowledge management at the National Center for State Courts. He recently contributed the article, 鈥�,鈥� to a volume published by the American Bar Foundation called 鈥�.鈥澨�
Moon said that she believes Tashea鈥檚 article is incredibly timely because of the current landscape of rapidly building new justice technologies.听 She highlighted one major theme of Tashea鈥檚 research: adoption and impact are 鈥渢wo different things.鈥澨�
鈥淭he paper's bluntest finding is that we don't know what works in justice technology,鈥� Tashea said. 鈥淭he one thing that I point to that has the clearest evidence backing it is text message reminders to show up to court.鈥澨�
Multiple randomized controlled trials show a causal relationship between text message reminders for court and increased attendance in court, Tashea explained. Beyond that, he said, existing research does not provide significant evidence supporting many other technologies used in the justice system. One of the biggest issues his article identifies is that there 鈥渋sn鈥檛 an accepted definition of what 鈥榮uccess鈥� means for a justice technology.鈥澨�
Tashea explained what he鈥檚 observed over more than a decade working in and studying the legal technology space.听
鈥淭here was this permeating theory from the leadership of the justice reform movement at the time [which] was 鈥榣et a thousand flowers bloom,鈥� make the funds available for people to go run pilots, to test new ideas, build new products, make new promises, and let's just see what happens,鈥� Tashea said. 鈥淎nd after more than a decade of letting flowers bloom, we have the field, right?鈥澨�
鈥淭he field is full of a bunch of flowers that have bloomed 鈥� we still don't know which one's poisonous, which one's medicinal, which one we should be taking to market,鈥� he continued. 鈥淎nd that's the metaphor I think about when I think about justice technology generally. We've got a lot of options out there and very little proof that any of it does anything.鈥澨�
Tashea鈥檚 hope is that more rigorous research can help the justice sector understand which tools meaningfully improve outcomes for the people they are intended to serve.
To hear鈥痶he rest of鈥痶his conversation, listen to the鈥�痮nline, on Spotify,鈥痀ouTube鈥痮r Apple Podcasts. The podcast is sponsored by 快猫视频鈥檚鈥� 鈥�����
